Review by Buffy for Morningstar Guide to Mutual Funds: Five-Star Strategies for Success
Rating:
This book provided a good broad-based overview of mutual funds and endorses modern portfolio theory. The idea being that a properly allocated portfolio of mutual funds with a focus towards long-term investing will work the best for most investors building their retirement savings. Properly balanced over the years, this style will work better than that of active investors trying to chase hot funds and time the market since very few active managers succeed over the long haul.

If you were to look at a “Top 10″ performing mutual fund from 10 or 5 years ago, chances are it isn’t a Top 10 fund anymore so you shouldn’t buy into the hype of today’s current “hot fund”. If it were such a solid fund, shouldn’t it be a solid fund 10 years later? But this book and similar ones feel that while an active investor and a hot fund may have one good year, they probably have bad years as well, and they probably can’t keep up their above-average performance over 30 years.

I read this book along with “All About Asset Allocation” by Richard Ferri and “The Only Guide to a Winning Investment Strategy You’ll Ever Need: The Way Smart Money Invests Today” by Larry Swedroe all of which cover similar ground (an overview of mutual funds, an overview of modern portfolio theory). My favorite is the Swedroe book because of it’s straightforward reading style, and it goes a little more in-depth than the Morningstar book.

The Morningstar book only gets 3 stars because unfortunately Morningstar has a product to sell: namely, Morningstar itself. Morningstar makes money buy getting you to use their services (such as their web site) and rely on their ranking system and advice all of which comes through in this book. Morningstar’s 5-Star ranking system can create some of the problems Hot Top 10 Funds lists create: they tempt everyone into thinking if it’s a 5-star fund it HAS to be good so why not buy the hot 5-star fund that posted a 30% return last year? Why would anyone buy a 5-star fund with a 12% return? But not all of Morningstar’s 5-star funds stay 5-star funds so you have to look past the hype when deciding for yourself if a fund is good for you for the next 5, 10, 20 years. The book was okay but be mindful of the Morningstar product placement. The Swedroe book gets my recommendation.

Review by Dennis McCroskey for Morningstar Guide to Mutual Funds: Five-Star Strategies for Success
Rating:
The book reads somewhere between a text book and a general description of mutual funds and bonds. I found it to be very informative, well organized and believe I have a much better understanding of how mutual funds work. Also, Crhistine is pretty cute.

Review by Henry Kwok for Morningstar Guide to Mutual Funds: Five-Star Strategies for Success
Rating:
Concrete introductory book to mutual fund tradings, some illustrative examples to trigger further researches. Chapter on comments on the strength and weakness of various fund companies are especially useful. Two weakness of this book: the first one is the fact that it is published in 2005, which is in the middle of a bull market and thus may not therefore be up to date. More up to date information should therefore be sought online in the Morningstar website as well as other websites. The second weakness is the relative lack of comments of the international perspectives, especially on emerging markets like China and Latin America.